• News

On The Permissibility Of Muslim Military Personnel Within The U.S. Armed Forces Participating In The War Operations And Related Efforts In Afghanistan And In Other Muslim Countries


This question presents a very complicated issue and a highly sensitive situation for our Muslim brothers and sisters serving in the American army as well as other armies that face similar situations.

All Muslims ought to be united against all those who terrorize the innocents, and those who permit the killing of non-combatants without a justifiable reason. Islam has declared the spilling of blood and the destruction of property as absolute prohibitions until the Day of Judgment.

We ordained unto the Children of Israel that if anyone killed a human being unless it be in punishment for murder or for spreading mischief on earth it would be as though he killed all of humanity; whereas, if anyone saved a life, it would be as though he saved the life of all humanity. And indeed, there came to them Our messengers with clear signs (proofs and evidences), even then after that, many of them continued to commit mischief on earth.

- God (Glory be to He)

Hence, whoever violates these pointed Islamic texts is an offender deserving of the appropriate punishment according to their offense and according to its consequences for destruction and mischief.

COPYRIGHT_IO: Published on https://www.islamopediaonline.org/permissibility-of-muslim-military-personnel-within-the-us-armed-forces-participating-in-the-war-operations-and-related-efforts-in-afghanistan-and-in-other-muslim-countries/ by Aaliyah Azeena on 2022-10-13T12:32:46.452Z

It's incumbent upon our military brothers in the American armed forces to make this stand and its religious reasoning well known to all their superiors, as well as to their peers, and to voice it and not to be silent. Conveying this is part of the true nature of the Islamic teachings that have often been distorted or smeared by the media.

If the terrorist acts that took place in the U.S. were considered by the Islamic Law (sharia) or the rules of Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), the ruling for the crime of "hirabah" (waging war against society) would be applied to their doers.

The recompense of those who wage war against God and His Messenger and do mischief on earth is only that they shall be killed or crucified or their hands and their feet be cut off from opposite sides, or be exiled from the land. That is their disgrace in this world, and a great torment is theirs in the Hereafter. Except for those who (having fled away and then) came back with repentance before they fall into your power; (in that case) know that God is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.

- God (Glory be to He)

Therefore, we find it necessary to apprehend the true perpetrators of these crimes, as well as those who aid and abet them through incitement, financing or other support.

They must be brought to justice in an impartial court of law and punish them appropriately, so that it could act as deterrent to them and to others like them who easily slay the lives of innocents, destroy properties and terrorize people.

And help one another in virtue and righteousness, but do not help one another in sin and transgression.

- God's (Most High)

On the other hand, the source of the uneasiness that American Muslim military men and women may have in fighting other Muslims is because it's often difficult if not impossible to differentiate between the real perpetrators who are being pursued, and the innocents who have committed no crime at all.

When two Muslims face each other in fighting and one kills the other, then both the killer and the killed are in the hell-fire. Someone said: we understand that the killer is in hell, why then the one who's being killed? The prophet said: because he wanted to kill the other person.

- Bukhari and Muslim

The noble Hadith mentioned above only refers to the situation where the Muslim is in charge of his affairs. He is capable of fighting as well as capable of not fighting. This Hadith does not address the situation where a Muslim is a citizen of a state and a member of a regular army.

In this case, he has no choice but to follow orders, otherwise his allegiance and loyalty to his country could be in doubt. This would subject him to much harm since he would not enjoy the privileges of citizenship without performing its obligations.

The Muslim (soldier) must perform his duty in this fight despite the feeling of uneasiness of "fighting without discriminating." His intention (niyya) must be to fight for enjoining of the truth and defeating falsehood. It's to prevent aggression on the innocents, or to apprehend the perpetrators and bring them to justice.

It's not his concern what other consequences of the fighting that might result in his personal discomfort, since he alone can neither control it nor prevent it. Furthermore, all deeds are accounted (by God) according to the intentions. God (the Most High) does not burden any soul except what it can bear.

In addition, Muslim jurists have ruled that what a Muslim cannot control he cannot be held accountable for.

And keep your duty to God as much as you can when I ask of you to do something, do it as much as you can.

- God (the Most High)

The Muslim here is a part of a whole, if he absconds, his departure will result in a greater harm, not only for him but also for the Muslim community in his country - and here there are many millions of them.

Moreover, even if fighting causes him discomfort spiritually or psychologically, this personal hardship must be endured for the greater public good, as the jurisprudence (fiqhi) rule states.

Furthermore, the questioner inquires about the possibility of the Muslim military personnel in the American armed forces to serve in the back lines - such as in the relief services' sector and similar works.

If such requests are granted by the authorities, without reservation or harm to the soldiers, or to the other American Muslim citizens, then they should request that.

Otherwise, if such request raises doubts about their allegiance or loyalty, cast suspicions, present them with false accusations, harm their future careers, shed misgivings on their patriotism, or similar sentiments, then it's not permissible to ask for that.

To sum up, it's acceptable God willing for Muslim American military personnel to partake in the fighting in the upcoming battles, against whomever, their country decides, has perpetrated terrorism against them.

Keeping in mind to have the proper intention as explained earlier, so no doubts would be cast about their loyalty to their country, or to prevent harm to befall them as might be expected.

This is in accordance with the Islamic jurisprudence rules which state that necessities dictate exceptions, as well as the rule that says one may endure a small harm to avoid a much greater harm.

This fatwa was issued by Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi (Grand Islamic Scholar and Chairman of the Sunna and Sira Council, Qatar), Judge Tariq al-Bishri (First Deputy President of the Council d'etat, Ret., Egypt), Dr. Muhammad S. al-Awa (Professor of Comparative Law and sharia, Egypt), Dr. Haytham al-Khayyat (Islamic Scholar, Syria), Mr. Fahmi Houaydi (Islamic Author and Columnist, Egypt), Sheikh Taha Jabir al-Alwani (Chairman of the North America Fiqh Council, Sterling, Virginia).

It was published in The Washington Post on October 11, 2001. The inquiry was presented by Mr. Muhammad Abdur-Rashid, the senior Muslim chaplain in the American Armed forces prior to the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan in October 2001. In his question he states that the goals of the (war) operations are:

  • Retaliation against those "who are thought to have participated" in planning and financing the suicide operations on September 11th, against civilian and military targets in New York and Washington (he then detailed the consequences of these operations.
  • Eliminating the elements that use Afghanistan and elsewhere as safe haven, as well as deterring the governments which harbor them, sanction them, or allow them the opportunity for military training in order to achieve their goals around the world.
  • Restoring the veneration and respect to the US as a sole superpower in the world.

Furthermore, he concludes his inquiry by mentioning that the number of Muslim military personnel in the three branches of the American armed forces exceeds fifteen thousand soldiers.

Hence, if they refuse to participate in the fighting, they will have no choice but to resign, which might also entail other consequences. Finally, he asks if it is permissible for those who can transfer to serve in different capacities other than direct fighting.

Share: Twitter | Facebook | Linkedin

About The Authors

Aaliyah Azeena

Aaliyah Azeena - Aaliyah Azeena is using her own voice to speak up for ourselves, the Musilm and kickstart an open honest dialogue about Islam in today’s society. She is raising the place of Muslim women in mainstream society, drawing awareness to the Qur’an’s message of gender equality and Islam’s principle of peace. Aaliyah is paving the way toward a world in which every woman can raise her head without fear of being attacked for her gender or beliefs. She is pioneering our own paths as Muslim women living in today’s modern society, and this is our story.

Recent Articles

  • Religion Law And Iraq - The Way It Affects The Global Society


    Religion Law And Iraq - The Way It Affects The Global Society

    What comes to your mind when you hear religion law and Iraq? Some people might not have enough ideas about how these are all connected and significant to the world. Balancing justice with long-term peace and security in a post-conflict context is extremely difficult. The challenges in Iraq's post-IS (Islamic State) landscape are discussed in this article.

  • Fatwa - An Interesting Islamic Ruling


    Fatwa - An Interesting Islamic Ruling

    When news broke on August 12, 2022, that the writer Salman Rushdie had been attacked, many people immediately remembered the fatwa, or edict, issued in 1989 by Iran's Supreme Leader at the time, Grand Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, calling on all Muslims to kill him. Rushdie's 1988 novel, "The Satanic Verses," was accused by Khomeini of insulting Islam and blaspheming the Prophet Muhammad. Riots and credible death threats drove Rushdie into exile, where he spent the next nine years under British police protection. He did not resurface until 1998, after Iran promised not to enforce the fatwa but did not rescind it.

  • Dr. Ali Goma - Egyptian Islamic Scholar, Jurist, And Public Figure


    Dr. Ali Goma - Egyptian Islamic Scholar, Jurist, And Public Figure

    Dr. Ali Gomaa is the Grand Mufti of Egypt. He was born on March 3rd, 1952 in Bani Suwaif. He studies at the Faculty of Commerce, and then after graduating, he completed another bachelor’s degree from Al-Azhar in 1979, followed by two masters and a PhD degree in 1988. Before becoming the Grand Mufti, he was Professor of Juristic Methodologies at Al-Azhar University.

  • Pakistan Transnational Influences And Militancy - The Effects To The Society


    Pakistan Transnational Influences And Militancy - The Effects To The Society

    Pakistan transnational influences and militancy, have huge effects in the society. The growing influence of the terrorist group known as the Islamic State (IS) is a worrisome. Terrorist organizations like Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State frequently rely on local militant groups to establish new affiliates or branches around the world. While previous research has primarily focused on the motivations of groups to align, as well as the effects of alliances on the lethality.

  • Sayyad Muhammad Hussein Fadlallah Lebanon Responds To Question If It's Permissible To Take Loans If You're Non Islam - The Shariah View


    Sayyad Muhammad Hussein Fadlallah Lebanon Responds To Question If It's Permissible To Take Loans If You're Non Islam - The Shariah View

    He is known as Grand Ayatollah Mohammad Hussain Fadlallah. He was born in Lebanon on November 16, 1935 and died on July 4, 2010. He was a renowned Shia cleric. Following his education in Islam in his hometown of Najaf, Iraq, Fadlallah emigrated to Lebanon in 1952. In the years that followed, he started the Mabarrat Association, spoke a lot, did a lot of research, wrote many books, and set up a lot of Islamic religious institutions.

  • Abdu Zubayr - His Biography, Conversion, And Legacy


    Abdu Zubayr - His Biography, Conversion, And Legacy

    In the service of the caliphs Abu Bakr (r. 632-634) and Umar (r. 634-644), Abdu Zubayr ibn al-Awwam was an Arab Muslim commander who took part in the early Muslim conquests of Sasanian Iraq (r. 633-634), Byzantine Syria (r. 634-638), and the African Exarchate (r. 639–643). Through Qusai ibn Kilab, a Quraish chieftain in Mecca who was in his fourth generation, he also shared lineage with Muhammad.

  • Hosseini Nassab Seyed Reza - A Co-founder Of Various Islamic Institutions


    Hosseini Nassab Seyed Reza - A Co-founder Of Various Islamic Institutions

    Grand Ayatollah Seyed Reza Hosseini Nassab (b. 1960) studied at taught at Qom Seminary from 1976 to 1991. In 1991, upon accomplishment of three thesis in Islamic Jurisprudence, Astronomy and acknowledgment of Shi'a faith, he received Professorship Certificate a doctorate degree from the Qom Seminary. He has co-founded a number of Islamic institutions in various major cities in Canada, Germany, and Switzerland, and currently resides in Toronto, Canada.

  • Al-Nour Party Calls On Copts Join


    Al-Nour Party Calls On Copts Join

    Emad Eddine Abdel-Ghaffour, acting President of Al-Nour Party, called on Christians to join the party, stressing that the party is for all Egyptians and is not restricted to any one group. He also said that the party has created a committee to establish contacts with Copts and Nubians, as well as professionals such as college professors and experts in different fields.

  • Youm7 - Daily Egyptian Newspaper


    Youm7 - Daily Egyptian Newspaper

    Youm7 is a daily, electronic newspaper based in Cairo, Egypt. Formed in October 2008, Youm7 was initially a weekly paper; it became daily on May 31, 2011. Youm7 also launched its English-language website in May 2011, "with the goal of providing quality coverage of Egyptian news in English."

  • Muhammad Sayyid Tantawi - The Grand Imam Of Al-Azhar Mosque

  • Atiyyah Saqr - Writer And Consultant For The Egyptian Ministry Of Awqaf

  • Mohamed Abdel Salam Faraj - Co-Founder Of The Egyptian Islamic Jihad

  • Khairat El-Shater - Deputy Of The Supreme Guide

  • Hilaludd - President Of China Islamic Association Since 2001